Quality in the universities
One of the key developments in the higher education sector over the past two decades is the arrival of what is sometimes called the ‘quality movement’. In a nutshell, the various stakeholders of the universities have been less and less willing to take on trust that the teaching and research in these institutions is of high quality and have sought ways in which this could be independently verified.
In the UK this led to the quality assessment process overseen by the Quality Assurance Agency (the QAA), and the Research Assessment Exercise. It has been argued that these two mechanisms may have, at least initially, had a very doubtful impact on quality, though their quantitative impact may have been clearer (not to mention the bureaucratic impact). On the other hand, there can be little doubt that these processes made both the institutions and their staff acutely aware of the need to demonstrate the value of delivery of the universities’ core mission.
In Ireland the universities established the Irish Universities Quality Board, to which the governing authorities of all the institutions have ceded certain tasks for maintaining a framework of quality assurance and improvement. It has had an important role in developing and sustaining a framework of regular and public reports for each university and for academic units and programmes.
I propose to look again in a future post at the success of the Irish model, but it seems to me that a question we must ask initially is the key one: what actually constitutes ‘quality’ in a university, and if you want to measure it, what do you measure and how? These questions appear simple enough, but are in fact extremely complex. The British experience may be instructive, as a good deal of what was done initially to introduce quality assurance mechanisms may have been less than ideal; in Ireland we have an opportunity to learn from that.
So in my next post on this blog, I propose to attempt an answer to the question of what constitutes quality. Then after that, I shall look briefly at how our initiative with the IUQB has worked.
In the meantime, I would welcome comments.
Tags: Irish Universities Quality Board, IUQB, QAA, quality assurance, Quality Assurance Agency, quality improvement
You can comment below, or link to this permanent URL from your own site.
December 9, 2008 at 1:24 pm
[…] Anyway, you can read the report for yourself here and judge for yourself. And – something that is perhaps just as useful as a lengthy report – DCU president Ferdinand von Prondzynski (a gentleman who I don’t always agree with, but is never unwilling to get stuck into a debate with a thoughtful few paragraphs or more) has been writing about quality on his blog of late, including a quick overview of the UK and Irish situations. […]